
A Tree Grows in Brooklyn -if you want old-school classics, start here
Even though we don’t live in Yorkshire any more we get the Yorkshire Post on a Monday to read the Huddersfield Town match report. It wasn’t that which vexed me for once but an article in the main paper by journalist Sarah Freeman. The headline was ‘Read all about it: 10 books to tempt teenagers into literature.’ Great, I thought - something about books.
Ms Freeman began by quoting ‘a recently published top 10 survey’ that had listed Harry Potter (which one?) The Da Vinci Code and Gillian McKeith’s You are what you eat’ among its recommended reads for teens. Without being able to check her sources (I am always suspicious of journalists who quote ‘recently published surveys’. Is it another way of saying ‘I am inventing this survey as I have a column to fill so I’ll keep it vague?) Anyway, I agree with Freeman that such inclusions as McKeith’s seem a little odd but I found her own ‘definitive list’ even more odd especially as she added that the list of books was one that ‘…every teenager should be forced to read.’
Forced to read? Forced? Since when has forcing a teenager to do anything led to a positive outcome? And since when should reading be something you force upon anyone? Reading should be a joy, a pleasure, a life skill people of all ages do as naturally as breathing. However we all know the joy of reading diminishes when other things take over like GCSEs, relationships, Facebook and bottles of WKD. It returns in the mid 20s after graduation. Trust me on this one.
The other thing that cheesed me off about Freeman’s list was how outdated it was. Has she even been in the young adult section of a book shop since 1983? While her list is irrefutably worthy and stuffed full of more classics than Delia’s cookbook, only the most avid will-go-on-to-study English-at-Uni- reader would thrive on it. Someone needs to send her a copy of The Ultimate Teen Book Guide (Hahn & Flynn) - and fast.
I’ve come up with my own equivalent to Sarah Freemans’ list (mine in blue). I’m not saying mine are better books, just more likely to be read through to the end by today’s ‘Youtube’ generation. Here goes:
Lord of the Flies by William Goldman
Malarkey by Keith Gray, Looking for JJ - Anne Cassidy
Animal Farm by George Orwell
The Handmaid’s Tail - Margaret Atwood, How I live Now - Meg Rosoff
To Kill a Mockingbird - Harper Lee
Caught in the Crossfire - Alan Gibbons, Noughts and Crosses - Malorie Blackman
The Hobbit - JRR Tolkein
any Discworld books - Terry Pratchett
The Curious Incident of the Dog at Night-time by Mark haddon
(I’ll let her off with this one - it’s only a decade old and captured the zeitgeist)
The Secret Diary of Adrian Mole - Sue Townsend
Rachel Riley my so-called life - Joanna Nadin (a total rip-off of Mole but with more up-to-date references) or any Louise Rennison or Sue Limb.
Dracula - Bram Stoker
City of Bones by Cassandra Clare - vampires etc but better written than Twilight
The Catcher in the Rye - JD Salinger
Who is Jesse Flood - Malachy Doyle
The Wasp Factory - Iain Banks
Rowan the Strange - Julie Hearn
A Clockwork Orange - Anthony Burgess
Bloodtide - Melvin Burgess, Daz 4 Zoey - Robert Swindells
There are loads more I could add in general but I’ll save those for another post!